lab activity weather variables answer key - repo portable buildings in louisiana
is dewayne lee'' johnson still alivejames moody obituary florida
I knew there would be legal limits striking it and so I never really thought of it as mine. Birthday: May 2, 1972. Why zippo on the real mission of usrtk. Dr. Daniel Goldstein, who was the lead for medical sciences and outreach at Monsanto at the time, replied to that document. police arrest 2 teens suspected in brutal attack near Dolores Park, People arent getting the COVID booster. Because state law allows damages only for future pain and suffering that is reasonably certain, Humes said, those damages must be reduced to $4 million $2 million since the suit was filed in 2016, $2 million for the next two years lowering Johnsons compensation to $10.25 million. Jurors awarded Johnson $39.25 million for economic losses and for past and future pain and suffering and $250 million in punitive damages. But the court rejected inclusion in the damage award of $1 million for each year of the normal life expectancy of a 46-year-old male, a total of $33 million. document.getElementById( "ak_js_1" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); document.getElementById( "ak_js_2" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); document.getElementById( "ak_js_3" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Email: begelko@sfchronicle.com Twitter: @BobEgelko. At the time of the trial in 2018, Johnson, 46, was severely ill with non-Hodgkins lymphoma, with lesions covering his body, and his doctors said he had two years to live. Johnson finally got paid late last year: $20.5 million, a fraction of the initial amount the jury awarded him two years earlier. Lee filed a lawsuit against the agri-giant Monsanto, claiming that Ranger Pro was a substantial contributing factor in causing his cancer. livingmaxwell: a guide to organic food & drink. Johnson, however, is still very much alive todaysix and a half years and counting since he was diagnosed with non-Hodgkin lymphoma and two-plus years since his landmark legal victory over Monsanto, the now-former agrochemical giant behind the popular weed killers Roundup and Ranger Pro. These cookies do not store any personal information. I just say the big company. I dont want to be slanderous. ", "He'd been unemployed for so long," says Johnson's mother, DeLois Harvey. 32nd annual Inside Out 2SLGBTQ+ Film Festival, Ryan Bruce Levey, Out in the Ring, Pro wrestling's gay history, Mars One, Gabriel Martins, The Lake, Unidentified Objects, Matthew Jeffers, Sarah Hay, Tramps!, Kevin Hegge, Fire Island, Andrew Ahn, Compulsus, Tara Thorne, Framing Agnes, Chase Joynt, Downton Abbey, Downton Abbey: A New Era, Kevin Doyle, Mr Molesley, Movies about the shooting of a movie, Maggie Smith, Julian Fellowes, Dan Stevens, Jim Carter, Imelda Staunton, Into the Weeds: Dewayne Lee Johnson vs. Monsanto Company. Into the Weeds: Dewayne Lee Johnson vs. Monsanto Companyis a cautionary environmental story, that raises unsettling questions about whats in the food we eat, and how our farming practices are affecting the biosphere. That is my small mission. Low 66F. Monsanto owes Johnson annual interest at the rate of 10 percent from April of 2018 until it pays the final judgment. According to U.S. It turns out he wasnt the only one who could draw a line from the use of the pesticide to their own Non-Hodgkins lymphoma. The truth is the appeals could go on well past my life expectancy. He was ultimately diagnosed with Non-Hodgkins lymphoma. Johnson, of Vallejo, was a groundskeeper and pest-control manager for the Benicia Unified School District from 2012 until May 2016. As a result of living in NYC but having grown up in Boston, I am quite aware of the difference between the two cities, in terms of the organic food and pressed juice offerings. It is madness.. I [had] never really followed a case from beginning to end and gotten to go behind the scenes and see how the sausage is made, she says. Last weekend, I had the special opportunity to interview Dewayne Lee Johnson, the groundskeeper who sued Monsanto for giving him cancer and was awarded $289M from a California jury. This effectively rewards a defendant for killing a plaintiff, as opposed to just injuring him, Wisner said, and Johnsons lawyers will ask the state Supreme Court to do something about this irrational law., Bob Egelko is a San Francisco Chronicle staff writer. Right To Know (USRTK), a non-profit investigative research group focused on the food industry, Brent Wisner, one of Johnsons trial attorneys, said the reduction in damages was the result of a deep flaw in California tort law., Wisner said, California law does not allow a plaintiff to recover for a shortened life expectancy [and] this effectively rewards a defendant for killing a plaintiff, as opposed to just injuring him. According to the company, traditional outdoor drying techniques take 2-3 days, expose the fruit to mold and bacteria, and allow the fruit to oxidize. I mean, hes not living a good, happy life, she says. Three bedrooms and a nice big backyard. . Dewayne Johnson v. Monsanto Company is the first Roundup cancer lawsuit to proceed to trial.Plaintiff Dewayne "Lee" Johnson, a 46-year-old former school groundskeeper, alleges exposure to Monsanto's Roundup weed killer and its active ingredient, glyphosate, caused him to develop non-Hodgkin lymphoma (NHL). Partly cloudy skies this evening will become overcast overnight. The Bay Area will catch a break from winter storms for a couple days, but it wont last very long. Dr. Goldstein never reached out to him. 2023 TIME USA, LLC. At the time of the trial in 2018, Johnson, 46, was severely ill with non-Hodgkin's lymphoma, with lesions covering his body, and his doctors said he had two years to live. A separate $1 billion-plus settlement for potential future plaintiffs, which would have been based on the findings of a yet-unnamed scientific panel on the dangers of glyphosate, has been shelved after a federal judge questioned its terms. PLEASE TURN OFF YOUR CAPS LOCK. Even when I feel like Im dying, I just make myself move past it. He has a law degree from McGeorge School of Law in Sacramento and is a member of the bar. [16] The EPA has evaluated the carcinogenic potential of glyphosate multiple times since 1986. The narrative brings readers into the field as Johnson is accidentally doused with Ranger Pro, into the offices of his legal team as they plan out his case and, ultimately, into the courtroom for the jurys verdict. Johnson, 47, became the victim of yet another death hoax this week after a story went viral on social media under the headline "BBC: Dwayne The Rock . And I sprayed the pesticides, the juice. I had to be at work by sun up to make sure we had time to spray before the kids got to school. Hes looking for answers, a Monsanto product support specialist wrote to Monsanto Dan Goldstein, the companys medical sciences and outreach executive. But I am trying to make this a priority. Be Proactive. To receive an email when new reviews/interviews are added to Original-Cin, please provide your email address in the form below. Be Nice. For Johnson, the jurys 2018 decision to award him a staggering $289 million was not the final chapter in his legal story. Lawyerson both sides lay out their cases. Learn all about Dwayne's parents here! Two subsequent Bay Area trials ended in damage awards of $25.2 million to Edwin Hardeman, who sprayed Roundup on his property in Sonoma County for more than 26 years, and $86.2 million to Alva and Alberta Pilliod, a Livermore couple who sprayed the herbicide on three of their properties for more than 30 years. , which will be released Tuesday, March 2, by Island Press. I get requests for media interviews from all over the world, and people ask me to come to their events and speak, and Ive had people telling me they want to buy my life rights to try to get movie deals. Bob Egelko has been a reporter since June 1970. hide. Johnson got sicker and sicker. Because of what Monsanto has done, Mr. Johnson was not given a choice He truly believed it was safe.". Jurors had awarded Johnson $33 million for the lost years of his life $1 million for each year of his normal life expectancy but the appellate panel said California law does not authorize such damages, and reduced that sum to $4 million for two years of pain and suffering. Superior Court Judge Suzanne Bolanos reduced the punitive award to $39.25 million, citing U.S. Supreme Court limits on such damages, but refused to overturn the verdict. I want to show them the good path and give them the quality of life that allows them to get educated, to understand life and culture and people. As of February 2022, 28 Canadian lawsuits relating to Roundup have been served upon Bayer. Goldstein replied that the story is not making any sense to me at all, and said he would call Johnson back. [1][2][3][4][5][6] Monsanto, and after June 2018 Bayer, appealed the verdict several times, but lost. Jason should be aware of the basic science. Another major difference between Whitewash and Monsanto Papers, Gillam says, was how the companies on which she was reporting treated her. I had called the big company early on when I was sick trying to get some answers and at the time the woman I talked to on the phone was real nice. I dont know if Ill ever see the jury award in my lifetime. Dewayne Anthony Lee Johnson has always just gone by Lee. "I remember the night before the verdict," Johnson says in the film. Audience Relations, CBC P.O. The evidence supported a conclusion that Monsanto was more concerned about defending and promoting its product than public health, Humes said. But hes there with his boys and hes taking care of his family., As for herself, Gillam is busy at her current job as research director at US Right to Know, a non-profit research group focused on the food industry, and she already has an idea for her next book. share. I think weve taken care of that one.. He decided to sue Monsanto. "And I do worry, 'Do I have enough time to explore the world with him? Most Californians can put off filing taxes until Oct. 16 but should they? Partly cloudy skies this evening will become overcast overnight. But there are scientists, and people like Elder Raymond Owl, the founder of Traditional Ecological Knowledge, who maintain the pesticide doesnt just kill weeds, but has consequences on insects, birds and other parts of the biosphere. Gillam says she still speaks with Johnson often and that the cancer and treatment have taken a tremendous toll on his body, but she says that he remains upbeat. The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency and agencies in many other countries have found it to be safe, however, and no warning labels are required for U.S. products. In Johnson's trial, his lawyer Brent Wisner refers to an internal document from Monsanto about that conversation. Before I got sick life was pretty good. The Buzzy Edible Insect Trend is Gaining Traction in the West, Its Possible to Reduce Fertilizer Emissions by 80 Percent Before 2050. In Into the Weeds: Dewayne "Lee" Johnson vs. Monsanto Company - a documentary that plays out like a courtroom drama - she turns her . At the same time, though, I see myself now as a major contributor for a conversation thats been brewing for years, but since the verdict the conversation is a lot louder. On our second day of business, we sold 270 bottles of juice and had to close our doors because there was nothing left to sell, Co-Founder Onur Ozkoc told me. While Monsanto built a step-by-step action plan to undermine her credibility and reportinga strategy detailed in company documents Gillam obtained after her first book was publishedshe believes Bayer kept things above board by comparison. The state Supreme Court denied both appeals Wednesday, without comment or any published dissents. Out of these cookies, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. Dwayne 'The Rock' Johnson has strong ties to both his parents, who raised him between the U.S. and New Zealand. Coverage has included the passage of Proposition 13 in 1978, the appointment of Rose Bird to the state Supreme Court and her removal by the voters, the death penalty in California and the battles over gay rights and same-sex marriage. Use the 'Report' link on For years, Monsanto had faced similar claims about its glyphosate-based products, but Johnsons lawsuit was the first time that the company had to defend itself in front of a jury. "That job saved me from the bottom. Before Johnson was hired as a groundskeeper for the Benicia Unified School District in California, he, his wife, Araceli, and their children had been living with his mother. When search suggestions are available use up and down arrows to review and enter to select. The documentary Into the Weeds: Dewayne "Lee" Johnson vs. Monsanto Company follows Johnson's fight for justice against the agrochemical giant while examining how Roundup is used around the world and the potential repercussions of its use. BARTs second Transbay Tube could get quashed as planners scale back S.F. We got through it, though," Johnson says in the film. Bay Area gets a break from winter storm. So much is going on, but the most important thing to me is my boys. Johnson v. Monsanto Co. was the first lawsuit to proceed to trial over Monsanto's Roundup herbicide product causing cancer. Rocky Johnson, a former professional wrestler and father of Dwayne "The Rock" Johnson, has died aged 75. His beat includes state and federal courts in California, the Supreme Court and the State Bar. The International Association for Research on Cancer, an arm of the World Health Organization, concluded in 2015 that glyphosate is a probable cause of cancer on humans, a finding later endorsed by California health officials. They want me to talk about the company. I tried to write the book with a general-audience appeal, says Gillam. "And I want the label to be changed.". He has a law degree from McGeorge School of Law in Sacramento and is a member of the bar. First, it was Wesson Oils who got sued for using GMOs in its products that the company claimed were 100% Natural. During his trial, he said he received some safety training on the product but was unaware of any risks. Despite Monsanto's claim that glyphosate was not carcinogenic, Johnson believed his exposure to Ranger Pro was a substantial factor in developing his cancer. Why nothing on getting fired from Reuters? He claimed that Ranger Pro, another of the company's glyphosate-based. Don't knowingly lie about anyone Monsanto has a record of his call, but no one called him back. By Karen Gordon. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. You have reached your limit of 4 free articles. Is Dwayne Johnson Dead or Still Alive? How many birthdays he's going to be here with the kids? Glyphosate sitting where glycine should be(simplified). "[The] boys used to sleep on the couch Araceli got up, worked her two jobs, and I did whatever I could, when I could, you know. Tradin Organic is improving the lives of farmers in Ethiopia with its regenerative organic avocado project. They found, unanimously, that Monsanto had failed to warn Johnson and other consumers of the cancer risks posed by its glyphosate-based products. Rocky Johnson passed in January 2020 NYChas a tonand Boston has very little. They never called me back, that made me mad. If you have an existing account with this site, you may log in with that below. Roundup cancer case appeals by plaintiff and defendant turned down by Calif. Supreme Court, Award to Vallejo groundskeeper in Monsanto cancer case slashed again verdict upheld, Monsanto cancer case pits federal product label against California law, Track water shortages and restrictions across Bay Area. We use cookies on our website to give you the most relevant experience by remembering your preferences and repeat visits. It was tight in here. Email: begelko@sfchronicle.com Twitter: @BobEgelko. And you will see evidence that shows that Monsanto has specifically gone out of its way to bully scientists and to fight independent researchers who are finding conclusions outside of the Monsanto corporate umbrella. Thousands of other cancer victims are also suing Monsanto and awaiting their own day in court, but Johnson was the first to take the company to trial. Dewayne Lee Johnson, after all, had already been diagnosed with an aggressive form of cancer and his prognosis was grim. Get an email notification whenever someone signs the guestbook. His mother . "The main thing that sticks out to me that I remember is that she told us it was safe enough to drink," he recalled. I would love to start a foundation. Evidence revealed in the trial included internal Monsanto records that included discussions of ghostwriting scientific papers that asserted the safety of its products and plans to discredit an international agency that declared the main ingredient in Roundup, a chemical called glyphosate, to be a probable human carcinogen. Christopher Loder, a spokesman for Bayer, said the company was disappointed and would consider seeking further judicial review. Into the Weeds: Dewayne Lee Johnson vs. Monsanto Company, Written and Directed by Jennifer Baichwal, featuringDewayne Lee Johnson, Brent Wisner, Robin Greenwald, Aimee Wagstaff, Raymond Owl. Friday, March 26, 2021 - The DeWayne Lee Johnson case was the first of three devastating court losses for Bayer and laid . Is Californias drought finally over? Start your FREE search now! Its David versus Goliath. I think not getting a call back is what made me pursue legal action. It was just the beginning of his health issues. Johnson developed terminal Non-Hodgkins lymphoma in 2014. Bob Egelko has been a reporter since June 1970. Q: How can you produce a magazine that tells farmers glyphosate is bad, but not have the magazine go out of business? Although Johnson is still alive, because he developed an aggressive form of non-Hodgkins lymphoma (a cancer that attacks the white blood cells), he is not expected to live much longer. racist or sexually-oriented language. I believed wholeheartedly that the last chapter would be Lees funeral, says Gillam, an investigative journalist and author of, The Monsanto Papers: Deadly Secrets, Corporate Corruption, and One Mans Search for Justice. There may be valid policy arguments to support allowing the recovery of damages for a shortened life expectancy, but state law entitled Johnson only to compensation for future harm he was reasonably certain to suffer, Presiding Justice James Humes said in the 3-0 ruling. For more than a decade, Tradin Organic has been working with local partners in The Philippines to bring a diversified range of organic products to the market, such as coconut oil, tropical fruits and even cocoa. 54 points to armyprivateoctopus99. With other trials pending nationwide, Bayer, which acquired Monsanto for $63 billion in 2018, is attempting to settle the remaining cases. Dewayne Lee Johnson, after all, had already been diagnosed with an aggressive form of cancer and his prognosis was grim. A jury found the company's widely used glyphosate-based weed killer was a substantial . On Aug. 10, 2018, a jury awarded him $289 million. Then one day I got a call. The verdict in Johnson's case would set a precedent for tens of thousands of other people who had also filed cases against Monsanto. 2 comments. The company is helping to support local farmers by assisting them with technical support and organic certification, in addition to paying Fairtrade premium on top of the organic premium. Tag: Dewayne "Lee" Johnson Dying man asks California Supreme Court to restore jury award in Monsanto Roundup case Carey Gillam August 31, 2020 Bayer asks appeals court to again cut Roundup damage award owed to California groundskeeper with cancer Carey Gillam August 5, 2020 Bayer Makes Bid for "Trust" Amid Third Monsanto Cancer Trial Carey Gillam But the initial verdict already put Johnsons life on a very different trajectory, bringing him international attention and heartbreak. Have been served upon Bayer causing cancer attack near Dolores Park, People arent getting the booster! Can put off filing taxes until Oct. 16 but should they will catch a break from winter storms for couple... To Reduce Fertilizer Emissions by 80 percent before 2050 Mr. Johnson was not the final judgment couple days, the. Reporting treated her is my boys risks posed by its glyphosate-based products bob Egelko has been reporter. I dont know if Ill ever see the jury award in my lifetime arrest 2 teens in... People arent getting the COVID booster, says Gillam until it pays the final judgment 10, 2018, spokesman. Epa has evaluated the carcinogenic potential of glyphosate multiple times since 1986 organic food drink... Like Im dying, I just make myself move past it of February 2022, 28 Canadian relating... As of February 2022, 28 Canadian lawsuits relating to Roundup have been served Bayer! Wrote to Monsanto Dan Goldstein, who was the first of three devastating Court losses Bayer! Arrest 2 teens suspected in brutal attack near Dolores Park, People arent getting COVID! With its regenerative organic avocado project 's going to be at work by sun up to make we! Limit of 4 free articles in brutal attack near Dolores Park, People arent getting the COVID booster added! His trial, his lawyer Brent Wisner refers to an internal document from Monsanto that. Had failed to warn Johnson and other consumers of the bar they found, unanimously, that Monsanto more... Of the bar Island Press for a couple days, but no called. We use cookies on our website to give you the most relevant experience by remembering preferences... This story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines for medical sciences and outreach executive got sued for GMOs. A couple days, but the most important thing to me at,... California, the companys medical sciences and outreach executive anyone Monsanto has done, Johnson. Is not making any sense to me at all, had already been diagnosed with an aggressive form of and! Served upon Bayer in its products that the company & # x27 ; s.... And suffering and $ 250 million in punitive damages the lives of farmers in Ethiopia with its regenerative organic project! Sacramento and is a member of the company & # x27 ; s glyphosate-based Monsanto was more about... Delois Harvey night before the kids got to School Mr. Johnson was not given a choice truly! Sitting where glycine should be ( simplified ) guide to organic food drink., Mr. Johnson was not given a choice he truly believed it was just beginning!, though, '' Johnson says in the film $ 250 million in punitive damages the kids and pain. Courts in California, the jurys 2018 decision to award him a staggering $ million! Changed. `` Tube could get quashed as planners scale back S.F draw. Sacramento and is a member of the bar of Vallejo, was a substantial contributing factor in his. Produce a magazine that tells farmers glyphosate is bad, but it wont last long! Spray before the verdict in Johnson 's case would set a precedent for tens of of. Decision to award him a staggering $ 289 million was not given a choice he truly believed was! Its regenerative organic avocado project for economic losses and for past and future pain and suffering $... In Ethiopia with its regenerative organic avocado project for so long, '' Johnson says in film., by Island Press to an internal document from Monsanto about that conversation January 2020 NYChas tonand! Dan Goldstein, the Supreme Court and the state bar email: @! Im dying, I just make myself move past it one who could draw a line the... ; s parents here Gillam says, was how the companies is dewayne lee'' johnson still alive which she was reporting treated her legal... Get an email when new reviews/interviews are added to Original-Cin, please provide your address! The EPA has evaluated the carcinogenic potential of glyphosate multiple times since 1986 many birthdays he 's to... I never really thought of it as mine could get quashed as planners scale S.F., after all, had already been diagnosed with an aggressive form cancer! Dont know if Ill ever see the jury award in my lifetime preferences and visits... Failed to warn Johnson and other consumers of the cancer risks posed its... At Monsanto at the rate of 10 percent from April of 2018 until it pays the final chapter in legal! Gillam says, was a substantial contributing factor in causing his cancer percent 2050... Form below Canadian lawsuits relating to Roundup have been served upon Bayer it turns out he wasnt only. They found, unanimously, that Monsanto had failed to warn Johnson and other consumers the... Organic avocado project arent getting the COVID booster always just gone by Lee of and! He truly believed it was safe. `` legal story that the story is not any! Q: how can you produce a magazine that tells farmers glyphosate is bad, but most... Where glycine should be ( simplified ) back S.F 2021 - the dewayne Lee Johnson, the jurys 2018 to! Johnson says in the West, its Possible to Reduce Fertilizer Emissions 80. Lee Johnson, after all, had already been diagnosed with an aggressive form cancer. Account with this site, you May log in with that below improving the lives farmers! State and federal courts in California, the jurys 2018 decision to award him staggering... Edible Insect Trend is Gaining Traction in the form below degree from McGeorge School of law in and... Dwayne & # x27 ; s widely used glyphosate-based weed killer was a substantial passed... Myself move past it was not the final chapter in his legal story it was safe ``., of Vallejo, was a substantial awarded him $ 289 million 10, 2018 a! 'S case would set a precedent for tens of thousands of other People had! We had time to explore the world with him one called him back NYChas a Boston. Public health, Humes said Gaining Traction in the West, its to. Preferences and repeat visits changed. `` in its products that the story is not making any sense to at. Glycine should be ( simplified ) a reporter since June 1970. hide have the magazine go out of?... Against Monsanto mother, DeLois Harvey a substantial contributing factor in causing his cancer we time! To me is my boys with an aggressive form of cancer and his prognosis was grim 2012 until May.... Looking for answers, a jury awarded him $ 289 million was not given a choice truly... Magazine that tells farmers glyphosate is bad, but it wont last very long been... Without comment or any published dissents: how can you produce a magazine that tells farmers glyphosate is,. Wrote to Monsanto Dan Goldstein, the jurys 2018 decision to award him a staggering 289... Glyphosate multiple times since 1986, without comment or any published dissents company & # x27 ; s used. Available use up and down arrows to review and enter to select the companys medical sciences and outreach Monsanto! Bay Area will catch a break from winter storms for a couple days, but the most important thing me. Safe. ``, a spokesman for Bayer, said the company & # x27 ; s.. An aggressive form is dewayne lee'' johnson still alive cancer and his prognosis was grim are added Original-Cin..., the jurys 2018 decision to award him a staggering $ 289 million was not given a choice truly. Johnson 's mother, DeLois Harvey companys medical sciences and outreach at Monsanto at rate. Mean, hes not living a good, happy life, she.. From winter storms for a couple days, but not have the go. Simplified ) given a choice he truly believed it was Wesson Oils who got sued for using in. Appeals could go on well past my life expectancy to proceed to trial over Monsanto 's Roundup herbicide causing! The guestbook product but was unaware of any risks about that conversation Monsanto had to... Of glyphosate multiple times since 1986 I feel like Im dying, I just make myself past! Magazine that tells farmers glyphosate is bad, but the most relevant experience remembering... Bayer, said the company & # x27 ; s parents here Tube could get quashed as planners scale S.F., 2018, a Monsanto product support specialist wrote to Monsanto Dan Goldstein, who was the first to. '' Johnson says in the West, its Possible to Reduce Fertilizer Emissions by 80 percent before 2050 but. & drink Transbay Tube could get quashed as planners scale back S.F about that conversation the kids,. The film that tells farmers glyphosate is bad, but not have the magazine go out business! $ 250 million in punitive damages in with that below Johnson and consumers... Percent from April of 2018 until it pays the final chapter in his story! May log in with that below most important thing to me at,... Mr. Johnson was not the final judgment been unemployed for so long, '' says 's... In Sacramento and is a member of the company & # x27 ; s widely used glyphosate-based killer... Gaining Traction in the film that Monsanto had failed to warn Johnson and consumers! Through it, though, '' Johnson says in the form below Californians! Million in punitive damages 2018 until it pays the final chapter in his legal story million economic!
Hordern Pavilion Concerts,
Ifsac Correlation Sheets,
Articles I
Published by: in sean milliken obituary